The Origins and Development of Nikāya (Early Schools) Buddhism and the importance of lay followers and merchants in the early Buddhist “schools” tradition: 17th Gyalwang Karmapa, Mar-Ngog Summer Teachings (Day One)

17th Gyalwang Karmapa, Ogyen Trinley Dorje teaching on Day One of the Summer Mar-Ngog teachings (July 2026)

“For the last few years, I have been giving quite few teachings on various different times and themes. The main reason for this is that we need to increase our level of understanding of the development of ancient Buddhism, as it developed in ancient India, and it shouldn’t be only as it’s described in ancient Tibetan scriptures, but also the situations described in the scriptures of the Theravada and Chinese Buddhism. Of course, there’s also many Asian and Western scholars who’ve done a great amount of research, so we need to come to an understanding of the results of their research. So, this is important for all of us Tibetan Buddhists, and the sangha, and others, to have better understanding of this.”

Summary: Day One

After a considerable period without online teachings, it was refreshing and inspiring to see the 17th Gyalwang Karmapa, Ogyen Trinley Dorje teaching again. On the first day of the Mar-Ngok Summer 2026 Teachings, he continued his historical exploration of what is described as the “Origins of Secret Mantra.” He opened the teachings with a summary of some of the teachings he has been giving on the Origins of Buddhism, secret mantra teachings from the Fifty Verses on the Guru, and also Mind-Only teaching based on his research on the Chinese texts which are very complete on the Thirty Verses on Mind-Only, and how he hoped to continue with those in the future.

Although the title refers to Secret Mantra or Vajrayāna, the teachings begin with early Buddhism and examine how Buddhist communities, institutions, doctrines, and practices gradually developed into the traditions now associated with Mahāyāna and Vajrayāna Buddhism.

The 17th Karmapa explained that these teachings introduce the history and development of Buddhism during the period of the early schools. Although the eighteen schools are sometimes treated as a specialist or remote subject, understanding them is essential. Without a sound knowledge of early Buddhism, Nikāya Buddhism, and the philosophical traditions that arose from them, it is difficult to understand fully the later development of Mahāyāna and Secret Mantra.

Six Main Themes

The 17th Karmapa gave a list of six main themes he was going to explain:

• the origins of Nikāya Buddhism;
• the organization of the Buddha’s followers;
• the traditions and responsibilities of monastics;
• the role of donors and patrons;
• the importance of merchants in supporting and spreading Buddhism; and
• the development of the Abhidharma scriptures and philosophical analysis.

Historical Scope

First the Karmapa gave a description of how the period of Nikāya Buddhism [Author’s note: the term Nikāya Buddhism was coined by Masatoshi Nagatomi as a non-derogatory substitute for Hinayana, meaning the early Buddhist schools] began after the originally unified Buddhist Saṅgha divided, approximately one hundred years after the Buddha’s parinirvāṇa. The first major division was between the Sthavira and Mahāsāṃghika traditions. Over the following centuries, these two broad communities divided further into numerous sub-schools (Nikāya), conventionally described as the eighteen schools, although inscriptions and historical sources suggest that there may have been more than twenty. [Author’s note: Over 300 years, both branches fractured further into regional and doctrinal sub-sects, traditionally counted as 12 derived from the Sthaviravada and 6 from the Mahasanghika].

Monastic and Lay Communities

The schools themselves were principally monastic institutions, but Buddhism was sustained by the four-fold community of monks, nuns, male lay followers, and female lay followers. Monastics preserved the teachings through study, contemplation, meditation, and disciplined practice. Lay followers, kings, queens, merchants, and other patrons provided the material and social support that made this life possible. Lay devotees also built and maintained stupas, preserved sacred sites, and helped spread devotion to the Buddha throughout India.

A central theme of the first day was the relationship between monastic and lay Buddhist communities. The early Buddhist schools were principally monastic institutions, and monastics played the leading role in preserving, studying, and transmitting the teachings. Nevertheless, the Karmapa emphasized that lay followers—both men and women—were both indispensable to the survival and development of Buddhism.

Kings, queens, wealthy merchants, businesspeople, and other lay patrons provided the material and social support that enabled monastic communities to flourish. They donated land, funded monasteries, built and maintained stupas, and supported the preservation of sacred Buddhist sites. The well-known example of Emperor Aśoka illustrates the importance of royal patronage in spreading the Buddhadharma throughout India and establishing stupas in many different regions.

The Karmapa also referred to a theory advanced by some scholars concerning the eventual decline of Buddhism in India. According to this view, Buddhism became too heavily centred upon monastic institutions and insufficiently rooted within the wider lay population. When monasteries and monastic universities were destroyed during periods of foreign invasion and political upheaval, the institutional foundations of Buddhism were severely weakened. People assert that Buddhism had become a school mainly for monastics, and not for laypeople. Hindu traditions, by contrast, may have survived more successfully because they remained more deeply integrated into household, family, and lay religious life.  Here is a short clip I made of that section of the teaching (with specially created English sub-titles).

Patronage, Trade, and the Abhidharma

Royal and mercantile patronage gave monasteries the stability needed for sustained study and practice. Merchants were especially important because their travels carried Buddhism across regions, trade routes, and eventually to other countries. This secure environment also enabled monastic scholars to examine phenomena in increasingly fine detail, contributing to the emergence of the Abhidharma and the distinctive doctrinal systems of the different schools.

Another particularly interesting aspect of the teaching concerned the importance of merchants and traders. Merchants travelled extensively along regional and international trade routes, often crossing forests, deserts, oceans, and political boundaries. Through these journeys, they carried not only goods but also religious ideas, practices, and cultural influences. Their networks helped Buddhism spread beyond its original geographical centres and into new regions and countries.

The financial support of merchants and royal patrons also gave monastic scholars the stability and freedom necessary to devote themselves to sustained study, contemplation, meditation, and philosophical investigation. This environment contributed to the development of the Abhidharma, in which Buddhist scholars analysed consciousness, mental factors, material phenomena, causation, and the nature of reality with increasing precision and complexity.

The First Divisions in the Saṅgha

Accounts of the early schisms differ among Pāli, Chinese, Tibetan, and Sri Lankan sources. Some emphasize the dispute over the ‘Ten Points’ and the council of seven hundred monastics; others connect the division with differing views concerning the Five Points associated with Mahādeva. These differing records must be compared carefully rather than accepted uncritically.

The Karmapa then turned to the early divisions within the Buddhist Saṅgha. Historical accounts of these schisms differ considerably among Pāli, Sanskrit, Chinese, Tibetan, and Sri Lankan sources. Some traditions associate the first major divisions with a dispute over the so-called “Ten Points,” concerning questions of monastic discipline. Other accounts connect them with the “Five Points” attributed to Mahādeva and debates about the spiritual qualities of arhats.

Rather than accepting any single historical narrative uncritically, the Karmapa encouraged students to compare the available sources carefully. Differences between Buddhist textual traditions are themselves historically significant, because they reveal how different communities remembered, interpreted, and transmitted the history of Buddhism.

The unspoken perspective: women vs men in these communities?

From my own perspective as a woman, however, one important question remained largely unaddressed: the role of gender in the formation and division of these early Buddhist communities. Women were acknowledged as part of the fourfold Buddhist assembly, comprising monks, nuns, male lay followers, and female lay followers. Yet it was not discussed in detail how women participated in the doctrinal debates, institutional developments, councils, or schisms that shaped the Buddhist schools.

Were these disputes and divisions primarily conducted by male monastics and male scholars? Did nuns or female lay patrons influence the development of particular schools or philosophical traditions? Were women involved in preserving alternative interpretations that were later excluded from the dominant historical records?

The surviving sources may suggest that formal councils and doctrinal controversies were overwhelmingly dominated by men, but this should not simply be assumed. It remains an important subject for further historical research. Examining the contributions of nuns, female patrons, queens, merchants, and lay practitioners may provide a more complete understanding of how Buddhism actually developed.

Conclusion

Overall, the first day offered a valuable introduction to the social, economic, institutional, and philosophical foundations of Buddhist history. It demonstrated that the development of Buddhism cannot be understood solely through doctrines or monastic lineages. Buddhism was sustained through the interdependence of monastics and laypeople, teachers and patrons, scholars and merchants, men and women, and through the movement of ideas across cultures and geographical boundaries.

Understanding these early developments provides an essential foundation for appreciating how Mahāyāna and, eventually, the Secret Mantra Vajrayāna traditions emerged.

The 17th Karmapa emphasised that these teachings highlight the most important historical and doctrinal points while encouraging students to read widely, compare sources, and undertake further research. The aim is not merely to memorize the names of ancient schools, but to understand how Buddhist institutions, communities, patronage, philosophy, and practice developed together and prepared the ground for later Buddhist traditions.

Here is a short video clip (Tibetan with English subtitles) I created regarding the importance of layfollowers in the four-fold Buddhist communities for the preservation and survival of the monastic community.

FULL TRANSCRIPT: DAY ONE

First Day — Opening Remarks

Today is the first day of our 2026 Mar-Ngog summer teachings, our first day.

I’d like to offer my greetings to all the members of the Sangha, monks and nuns, for listening, as well as all of the faithful men and women, the householders and so forth. My Tibetan compatriots, the other people from the Himalayan regions, and everyone else, I’d like to have first of all, I’d like to wish you my greetings and wish you good health.

So for the last few years, I have been giving quite few teachings on various different times and themes. The main reason for this is, as you all know, is that we need to increase our level of understanding of the development of ancient Buddhism, as it developed in ancient India, and it shouldn’t be only as it’s described in ancient Tibetan scriptures, but also the situations described in the scriptures of the Theravada and Chinese Buddhism.

Of course, there’s also many Asian and Western scholars who’ve done a great amount of research, so we need to come to an understanding of the results of their research. And so,  this is important for all of us Tibetan Buddhists, and the sangha, and others, to have better understanding of this.

And particularly among the members of the sangha. So for this reason, for these month, some are teaching, so I’ve been using these scriptures of all of these three vehicles, and I have done this, but as I can, to bring all the words of the Indian Chinese and Tibetan scholars, ancient, and Asian and Western, and I have been trying to teach with all of these together in union, I’ve been making attempts to do it in this way.

So that’s one thing.

Now, from another perspective, it’s not just talking about it in terms of contemporary methods of study and research, but it’s also in order for us to study in the traditional ways and to have a proper way of listening to this.

And so this is where the secret mantra, particularly, we’ve begun the 50 verses on the Guru. And so we’ve completed that teaching under that, and I hope that in the future, I have to teach the Ocean of Samaya and other topics to continue these teachings.

So, so that’s where we won’t be just speaking in accord with contemporary research methods, but also in terms of the traditional ways of practice that we have. So I have been trying to explain this in the best way.

Now, I also thought that something would be the most benefit for the people in the shedras on the Mind-Only school. I thought that first speak about the tradition of the Mind-Only school. This is discussed in complete, in the Chinese Buddhist scriptures, they have been preserved in their entirety in the Chinese tradition. Also, for many various reasons,  such as the fact that many of us do not know the language, we have been unable to study them.  So I thought if I could offer a bit of service in this area, and I began teaching the Thirty verses of the Mind-Only. And my intention is in the future to be able to continue this.

We have already covered the ancient, rich and philosophy that the Brahmins  and so forth, prior to the study of Buddhism, how they spread the deeds of the Buddha, the social situation, the deeds of the Buddha.

And the events of Buddhism following the parinirvana of the Buddha. Following that we spoke about the seven elders of the Buddhism, the patriarchs, and we spoke about the second, third and other of the four of the other councils. And then also the various different presentations and opinions of these.  So I’ve spoken about all these, to a certain degree.

So, now my hope is to start with the 18 schools, to begin with the spread of the 18 schools and continue to discussing the spread of the Mahāyāna.  So that’s my hope for these teachings.

Introduction: Why the History of the Buddhist Schools Matters

One of the reasons why I need to speak about the history and development of Buddhism, during these Mar-Ngog summer teachings, is that many of us who hear about the 18 schools, there are probably quite a lot of people who have absolutely no interest in them. And there are probably some people who haven’t even heard of the names or even heard the words. Thus we have a little understanding of this.

This lack of understanding is a fault. It’s not something that we should think of as a quality.These 18 schools and so forth are important topics that we need to understand. For example, if we are unable to gain a good understanding of the history of the period of the Buddhism of the schools, the philosophies of the schools, then it will be difficult for us to have a complete understanding of the Mahāyāna Dharma that followed from it and then the secret mantra that followed from that.

It would be difficult for our understanding. It would have a true understanding of those. Thus if that happens, it’s like everything is dependent upon each other.

Thus from the fundamental level. So from a fundamental level, we it is very important to understand them.  If we do not understand the early Buddhism and the Buddhism of the period of the schools Nikāya Buddhism, then automatically, it will be unable to have a good understanding of the history of philosophy of Buddhism as a whole. Thus this is why it is so important for us to take interest in that.

In particular, thinking about the 18 schools and so forth, many Asian and Western scholars have researched these topics. They’ve written books about this,  written articles on this topic. There are innumerable books and articles. On the one hand, my own level of education is not very high. And because if we have to say a lot, there’s not enough time, so I will.

So primarily I will emphasize and bring out those points that I think seem to me to be the most important and teach them as best I can. And in the future, it’s possible for those many people who know several languages and if they could just not believe things just because I have said them, but instead do more research and reading. And best of all, actually do real research. And if they are able to do good research into these topics, I think it would be extremely beneficial.

So I’ve said this is sort of like an introduction. So, now for our discussion.

Opening slide for Day One of the 17th Karmapa’s teachings on Early Buddhism (Nikaya/Depai Nangten)

These are the topics for the Nikaya Buddhism and the supporting history.

• the origins of Nikāya Buddhism;
• the organization of the Buddha’s followers;
• the traditions and responsibilities of monastics;
• the role of donors and patrons;
• the importance of merchants in supporting and spreading Buddhism; and
• the development of the Abhidharma scriptures and philosophical analysis.

So these are the basic discussions.  I just want to talk about the origin.

1. The Origins of Nikāya Buddhism

These are the Nikāya of the schools, which means the 18 schools.  And we talk about the Depai Nangten or the system of the schools. What is the time period that this happened? Thus it was the beginning of Buddhism, but it had been unified. Then after that, gradually, about 100 years after the Buddha passed into parinirvāṇa,  the monastic Saṅgha of the early Buddhists, split into two.—the Sthavira nikāya and the Mahāsāṃghika—during or after the Second Buddhist Council.

After these schools had appeared, there is the beginning of the period of Nikaya Buddhism, the period of the eighteen schools. This is a long time period, several centuries long. But the beginning of this is, as I just said, is that after the Saṅgha of early Buddhism split into the two, at that point there are these two different schools of the Saṅgha. Thus that is a brief introduction to the origin of the Nikaya School.

2. The Organization of Buddhist Followers: monastics, laypeople and comparisons with other world religions

So when we speak about the organization of Buddhist followers, the reason why we need to speak about this is that, in general when we speak about the time of the period of the schools, the Nikaya Buddhism, when we’re speaking about the students. And since it’s talking about the time of the monastic organization, but there are also other types of followers. For example, many faithful lay followers. There are many who had great faith in the Buddha. However, they were not included in the schools. Within the schools, there were only monastics.

The schools included only monastics, but there are many other followers of Buddhism, many other students. And the reason why is that they were primarily the lay householders. When we look at the historical documents, it’s not clearly described in historical documents how the lay practices practiced. But even though it’s not described, in the majority of the world’s religious traditions, there are the monastics and lay community. Whether we’re thinking about Hindu or Christian, all of them have two different communities of the monastic and the lay communities. Also, there are some that do not have two sects of lay and monastic. For example, there’s Islam, which has a very clear prohibition against monasticism. It states  clearly that it is not OK to practice monasticism or to practice celibacy. So for Islam, there is no monastic tradition. But for the others, there are both the monastic and the lay communities.

Within Buddhism,  among the followers, there is the group of the monastic followers and the group of the lay followers. Primarily the monastic community is considered the primary and the most important. However, that doesn’t mean you might wonder, are we completely disregarding the lay followers? That is not the case.

The reason is that we often speak about the four-fold community. The four different communities of Buddhism students. Thus these include the male and female lay practitioners, as well as the monks and nuns.So the lay practitioners include the upāsakas and upāsikās, the male and female lay practitioners. And then the monastic, the monks and nuns. When you count them in number, the lay householder practitioners, we can see that they are actually considered to be equally important as the monastic Saṅgha.

How the lay followers preserved and supported Buddhism: supporting monastics, the four sacred sites, the eight relic stupas, King Ashoka’s stupas

Generally, if we are trying to, in terms of achieving a high level of teaching and study Buddhism scriptures and listening, contemplation and meditating, the monastic community is extremely important because its function is to study Buddhism scriptures and to listen, contemplate, and meditate on them. The lay people don’t have the time to focus entirely on listening contemplation and meditation because they have so much work to do. So in terms of protecting the teachings, like a mother,  is the monastic Saṅgha. However, in order for that monastic community to exist, they need to have financial resources. They need societal support and they also need to be, you know, continue to be more monastics. Thus in order for that to happen, there has to be a lay community.

However, in later times, there were many invasions into India. For example,  at that time, Buddhism disappeared.  But Hinduism was able to continue to remain. So why is it that Hinduism remained and then Buddhism did not? One reason many scholars say is that Buddhism had become a religion solely for its monastics. So Buddhism had become a religion only for the monastic Saṅgha.  And when the monastic Saṅgha is destroyed, then it’s like Buddhism religion is relinquished. So there are some people  who hypothesize this.

The ancient historical documents do not describe clearly what the lay followers did to preserve Buddhism. And actually, but there are some certain details preserved in the historical documents. That show how the lay followers, were extremely active and diligent in spreading Buddhism throughout ancient India. For example, how can we know this, to give one example?

After the Buddha passed away, there were the sacred sites of the Buddha’s birth. But the place where he first turned the Wheel of Dharma and where he passed into parinirvāṇa.  These were the four sacred places. So these four sacred sites continue to be considered extremely important. Thus the people who primarily built and maintained the stupas there were primarily the lay followers. The ones who preserved them were the lay followers.

Likewise, after Buddhism passed into parinirvāṇa, his remains were divided into eight parts and distributed to eight different camps. There is the account, right? So, when the kings each got one part of the Buddha’s remains, each went to their own lands.

Thus in the different parts of the central India, they built the eight reliquary stūpas. The people who built these were all lay people.  The places where they were built were at places like major crossroads of highways. They weren’t built in the monasteries or the bhikṣus were, but in the place where people gathered at intercessions of major roads.

Likewise, there is the Mahāparinirvāṇa Sūtra in Chinese. I think there’s one in Pāli. And within those is how King Ashoka also built stupas.  The eight stupas were the remains the Buddha had distributed to the eight kings were enshrined, right?  So Ashoka opened his, and he then he divided into smaller parts, a smaller amount. And then he built lots of atupas throughout all of India. Because this is one of the stories that is told about King Ashoka is that he built many great stupas throughout India. And what this shows is that the practice of worshiping stūpas, of having faith for stupas had spread widely by that time.

The tradition of worshiping stupas had already occurred, developed during the period of early Buddhism. Because of this, this tradition gradually developed into worshiping and having faith in the Buddha. Praising the Buddha’s qualities, these also occurred. And these treasures later became a very critical point during the later spread of the Mahayana.

For that reason, we must not disregard and denigrate the influence lay practitioners who followed Buddhism and who practiced in their worship. And the effect that they had. It would be inappropriate to disregard them and ignore the contributions that lay practitioners made.

Originally called “Buddhist schools of the disciples/students” and how the term śrāvaka came to mean listener-hearers

What we’re speaking about, now is the Buddhism of the 18 schools, the Nikaya Buddhism.  The main people who were upholding the Buddha’s legacy at that time were still the śrāvakas who upheld the lineage of early Buddhism: the monastics. These are the disciples and the lineages that were passed down from the Buddha’s direct disciples, Mahākāśyapa and Ānanda.  So these are the non-broken lineages passed down from these great disciples.

With Nikaya Buddhism, many Buddhist students describe it as the Buddhism of the Disciples. Or the Buddhism of the parents of the different doctrines. The reason why there were so many schools is that there were many  disagreements about philosophy and doctrine among experts.

For this reason, they split into the different schools. At that time the Buddhism is that of the schools. Because it became the Buddhism of the  different doctrines, different philosophies.

Later, the Mahāyānists would call it all the Nikaya Buddhism, they would call it the listener vehicle or the śrāvaka Vehicle.  So śrāvakas were those people who heard and listened to the teachings given by the Buddha. But basically it means the disciples. You talk about the masters and disciples as teachers and students, it means the students. But even the early times, even lay people were also called śrāvakas, it seems.

However, later during the period of the Buddhism of the schools, when you said śrāvaka, it was understood only to be in monastic schools. There was no tradition of calling lay followers by the name of the śrāvakas. So that is basically the organization of these students.

3. The Monastic Tradition

So, following that we have the tradition of monasticism. So when you talk about the tradition of monasticism, the reason for talking about this is that one of the particular features of Nikaya Buddhism, the Buddhism of the schools, the tradition was primarily upheld by monastics. Thus, when you’re talking about the Buddhism of this period of the schools, you’re primarily talking about the monastics.

In essence, when you’re talking about the monastics, we are talking about those who have gone forth from home to homeless and then because they take vows and they become bhikṣus. And then once they become bhikṣus, they have to keep their vows purely and practice the dharma. Thus, for that reason at that time, there was a very clear distinction between householders and monastics. The monastics were not householders, and so there was extremely clear distinction between these two.

Thus the monastics primarily practiced the dharma. They kept the vows of the Vinaya dharma, and they concentrated on listening, contemplation, and meditation. They had a simple or contented way of life. They lived with few desires and were content with what they had. Thus they primarily focused on listening, contemplation and meditation. This is how they did. For this reason, the monastic lifestyle was not one that was practiced in markets, not in a group of people. Instead, it was in isolated monasteries, or there were very few people. And some places that were further out in the country. And these were the locations where they devoted themselves single-pointedly to perfecting their own practice first.

Thus during this period, they distanced themselves from the public. And they stayed only with other monastics and engaged in listening, contemplation, and meditation. Their primary responsibility was not framed as liberating others, but as perfecting their own practice.  Mahāyāna primarily talks about benefiting others and liberating other people. That’s the main thing in the Mahāyāna.

Instead, during the time of this school it is primarily in order for them to do their own practice, to perfect their own practice first. So for that reason later, Mahāyāna called it the Hinayana, or the lesser vehicle. Because they are at a lower level, they are inferior. They are not at a high level. They were calling them lesser.  Thus for that reason, they wouldn’t talk about the Hinayana. It is a derogatory, a critical name for that.

4. The Sponsors’ Tradition: Royal and Lay Patronage

Following that, I’d like to speak about the tradition of the various donors. When we talk about the tradition of the donors, what we mean is that at that time, the monastics didn’t have to worry about their livelihood. Instead, they could devote an focus their minds entirely on their practice, The main reason why the monastics could focus in this way is because they had no difficulty in their livelihood. If they have difficulties about getting food and so forth,  finding clothes, then you’re not going to be able to concentrate entirely and listen and count on meditation.

But at that time, monastics did not have to worry about their food or clothing, and instead, they could dedicate themselves entirely to listening contemplating and meditating. The main reason for this is that because the monasteries of that time were prosperous. They were thriving and were financially secure, and this is why this could happen.

The reason why this could happen is that at that time, many of the monastic communities at that time were worshiped, or the kings and queens and great merchants had gone to offer refuge to them and gave them great financial support. The sponsors donated a large tract of land for monasteries. For example, the story of King Kanishka went for refuge to the school and then gave great support to the Sarvāstivāda school. This is a very well-known story.

Even earlier than that, we think about the kings of ancient Northern India. There were many of them who had to create an offered large amounts of land to do this, and these are recorded in ancient rock and pillar inscriptions. Thus many of these have been found. Likewise, there are the kings and queens of the Andhra region of southern India, who also supported the monks and nuns of the Saṅgha. There are many inscriptions recording their donations of land and so forth to the Saṅgha.

Likewise, from more than a few of the inscriptions dating from this second century BC into the fifth century have been found. And many of them record how stūpas were built, how land was offered to the Saṅgha in order for them to build residencies and caves were offered and so forth. Thus because of these, we can know that at that time the kings and the queens and the great merchants gave great support to the monastic community. This is what they showed to them. Likewise, if we look at those inscriptions, we can see that at that time there were many Śrāvaka schools. There are many different, usually we sit in Tibet and we always talk about 18 schools. But when we look at this, when we research the inscriptions on these schools, it’s not only 18, they’re over 20.

Thus it’s important for us that we know about the 20 schools and more. This is the traditions of the donors.

5. The Importance of the Merchant Class and Business Leaders: Anāthapiṇḍika
Anāthapiṇḍika. Influenced by the teachings of the Buddha, Anathapindika bought Jetavana park, by spreading gold coins over entire land, to build a vipassana Centre.

The choice of the merchants. The reason why we need to speak about this is that at that time, not only did the Saṅgha receive support from the kings, they also received support from the merchant class. From the very first time that period of Buddhism spreading, the merchants were very important. For example, after the Buddha awakened, his first students were the merchants Trapusa and Bhallika.

These merchants were the first to offer alms to the Buddha after he reached enlightenment. And he taught them. Thus for that reason, the merchants were very important. Likewise, after the Buddha went to Sarnath and converted the group of five and turned the Wheel of Dharma.  After he had taken care of the group of five, there were many of the Buddha’s followers who were merchants.

Moreover, among the many important disciples of the Buddha, there was one, Anāthapiṇḍika who was a very rich merchant. Likewise, later times most, the first to carry Buddhism to many others in other lands, such as China and so forth, actually more of them were merchants than were monastics.

And the reason for that is that in the past times, most of the people who traveled were in the merchant class, and it wasn’t easy for a monastic traveler, it was not easy to travel at that time. Thus for that reason, it was through the merchants who were traveling through different places that Buddhism was spread.

This is not only Buddhism, this is also the same with Islamic Christianity, that many religions spread through because of merchants traveling. These merchants would gather many people in large caravans who travel through dense forests or across deserts, or they’d come to do business in distant cities, or some of them would embark on ships across the ocean, and engage in trade with other nations.

This is very dangerous, and there are a lot of hardships. Thus they had a sort of a decisiveness, and they had a lot of courage about this and also a lot of endurance. But for this reason, it’s actually why Buddha Dharma spread.

Not only that, when these Indian merchants went to other countries, they made connections with foreigners and people from many different social classes. In making such connections, they encountered social conditions different from those of ancient India.

There is the very strict caste system of their Brahmanical religion.  That’s the Brahmanic religion. If you take the Brahmanic system and you go to another other region, then it’s not really appropriate. It’s too strict. Thus Buddhism, the attitude toward the caste system, was more tolerant and free.

It actually met the needs of the merchants, actually. So it gave them exactly what they needed. Thus for this reason, many merchants became Buddhist and felt faith in Buddhism.

From another perspective at that time, in India, most of the farmers there basically never went abroad. They just lived wherever their predecessors had lived in. And they didn’t forget about going to other countries, they just never went to other regions. So most of them never went anywhere.

They would in the place that they’d been passed on from the ancestors, and so they continued the same that they continued the customs of their ancestors. The merchants went to other lands. And they met the people of different countries.

So if you try to follow all your own countries’ customs, when you go to another country, it’s difficult. Thus the past, so the Brahmanical rituals and traditions are very difficult to uphold if you travel to other countries. you get to the schools later. And many of those merchants also later had to develop faith in the Mahayana.

The Merchant/Business Leaders (Tsong-pon)

Among them, there were rich merchants and leaders. They were called business/merchant leaders (tsong-pon). Among these merchant leaders, there were many people who went for refuge to the Buddha, Dharma, and Saṅgha and supported the Buddha.

For example, Anāthapiṇḍika was also a merchant leader. Likewise, there is also the household Ugra. He was also a merchant leader.  Thus these were all very well-known merchant leaders within the Mahayana. There are many. There is the merchant leader’s son, Sudhana who is the main protagonist in the Gaṇḍavyūha Sūtra. And the Noble Aspiration for Excellent Conduct that we always recite, was taught by the Bodhisattva Samantabhadra to the business leader, Sudhana.

So from the time of early Buddhism onwards, many of the most important figures within Buddhism community were business leaders. And within Buddhism sutras, the merchant leaders often frequently appeared as the students to whom the Buddha primarily taught.  There are also many merchant leaders who supported the monastic communities during the time of Nikāya Buddhism.

6. The Development of the Abhidharma: due to the kindness of lay and business sponsors

Following this is the appearance of the Abhidharma. So when we speak about the appearance of the Abhidharma, what we’re speaking about is, in essence, Buddhist monastics were dependent upon others for their livelihood. They didn’t do anything to provide for their own lives.  It depended upon the donations of others, at that time, so the Saṅgha had no difficulty with its life.

But in the main, there were two different types of sponsors. One was the kings and the others were the merchants and merchant leaders.  So because of their support, the Saṅgha had no difficulty with the livelihood, its food and clothing. Because of this the monastics were able to devote themselves very comfortably to pursuing the supramundane path to its end. They were able to maintain that sort of courage and that sort of resolve to do this.

When you don’t have to worry about it your livelihood, then you can spend your time focusing entirely on research and practice. It is because of this, there is the topic of Abhidharma, which is basically making fine distinctions between the nature of phenomena. Being able to determine the fine distinctions of the presentations of all phenomena, that’s the Abhidharma, right?

Thus for that Abhidharma to develop, you need to have an environment and the support of not having to worry about your food and clothing. And then you can focus on that. If you’re not really certain about your food and clothing, and if you end up being hungry and naked, there’s no way you can worry about this. If you think it’s a single person like Milarepa, it is fine.

But if it was not just a few people,like thousands of people, they all stay in one place. And they need to practice listening, contemplation, meditation on the Dharma. They need to have support and people who support them because they had supporters, they were able to be comfortable.

If they didn’t have that, they wouldn’t have been able to practice the listening, contemplation, meditation. Therefore, it’s through the support of the kings and merchants that they were able to develop this great situation where they had the support. And because they were able to examine the nature of all phenomena, in great detail, and be able to produce the scriptures of the Abhidharma and so forth, which then gradually developed. It is becauseof that  they were able to develop full presentations and put the scriptures in the very school of doctrines.

During the time of early Buddhism, and during the time of the Buddha, there were not such different philosophical distinctions and so forth during the time of early Buddhism, as there were later during the time of the Buddha. Later, the complicated presentations of the nature of all phenomena developed. As the Saṅgha grew more numerous and their level of their learning grew, later at that point then their philosophical understanding reached a high level and became more encompassing.

7. Background to the Splitting of the Schools: the ten impermissible points

I’d like to speak about the introduction to the split into the schools. So, first we need to understand the background history. Second, I have an introduction to the related relevant documents. So first is the introduction to the background.

Last year during our summer teachings, what we discussed was the ten impermissible points. It was definitely ten points, and there was a question of whether these ten points are permissible or impermissible. There were two factions, one who said that they’re permissible, and another that said they’re impermissible.

I think if we say that the ten are impermissible, then it’s like we’re already holding one of the sides. And since there are two points, some who said it’s permissible and some impermissible, I think it’s better to just call them the ten points. Another point goes there are the five points of the Bhikṣu Mahadeva. The five points are the five views of Mahadeva.

We also discussed that. So we don’t need to spoke about this in detail, so just to talk about them generally. It’s basically about a hundred years after the Bhikṣu Mahadeva passed into parinirvāṇa. There was the dispute in the Saṅgha over the ten points, some said they were permissible, some said they were not permissible. And because of these points, there were 700 bhikṣus who came to Vaiśālī and held a council.

In the Pāli scriptures, it speaks about the 700 Bhikṣus, it investigated whether the ten points were impermissible with the Vinaya or not. Thus for that reason, they call this compilation of the Vinaya. But after the 700 arhats, there’s no description within this Pāli text as to whether they also compiled the recompile. there are also many other schools. There are other scriptures in the Chinese sources that are similar to the Pali ones. One of them, they’re saying that there was a compilation of that. But it was within the background stories. It only speaks about the dispute of the ten points, but it does not talk about whether they compiled the sūtras and Vinaya.
There are two important texts from from Sri Lanka, the Mahāvaṃsa, the Dīpavaṃsa, these texts talk about how there is [Unclear: a senior elder is named as the principal figure who promoted a compilation of the Dharma.] That means it’s a compiling the sūtras. Thus that this one took eight months.

And during that period, this was considered the second council. Because it also said in the Dīpavaṃsa is that the elders at that time, accused other bhikṣus of transgressing the Vinaya. So they kicked out these other bhikṣus.

Then all these other bhikṣus who had been kicked out gathered together. And they ended up being 10,000. Thus what they did is they had a compilation of the sūtras. Thus they called this the Great Compilation. Because they had over 10,000 people had performed in this. They called it the Great Council, the Great Compilation. This is written in the Mahāsāṃghika Code of Vinaya. At that time, there are 10,000 bhikṣus who compiled this. And they were called the name by the Mahāsāṃghikas.  This is a slightly different way of what it says, the Dīpavaṃsa.  They’re called by the name, but those are the Great Council within the Mahāsāṃghikas. They’re called the Mahāsāṃghikas.

In any case, this is what is written about the development of the Mahāsāṃghika Code. The reason why it’s called the majority school, and this is why. Because most people were lost to their side and this is why they had more people.  So they were called the Mahāsāṃghika, the majority Saṅgha.

Likewise, the Sri Lankan scriptures also described that these two sutras after these two Sthavira and Mahāsāṃghika schools, within each of these, they again hold counsels. These are written in these sutras.

8. Sources on the Original Split: Wheel Distinguishing the Different Schools (Nikāyabheda-vibhaṅga-vyākhyāna)

This is is described in an other tradition,  the northern tradition.  The most important source of this is a text called the Wheel Distinguishing the Different Schools. It’s written by the master Vasumitra, Indian Sarvāstivādin master, Vasumitra.  [ Author’s note: The “Wheel Distinguishing the Different Schools” (Nikāyabheda-vibhaṅga-vyākhyāna) is an ancient Indian Buddhist treatise and one of the most vital historical texts used to document and classify the early schisms of Nikāya (early) Buddhism that emerged roughly 100 to 200 years after the Parinirvāṇa (death) of the Buddha].

It’s also translated into Tibetan, but it had already been translated into Chinese, during the Tang dynasty, by Master Xuanzang. And in the Wheel Distinguishing the Different Schools, there is a description of whether there are castles. There’s no description of what they’re saying that it just goes about because of the castles of course. What it says in this Wheel Distinguishing the Different Schools is that there’s a hundred years past, in parinirvāṇa, the time of the King Aśoka.

During that time, there were four different communities. Who discussed the five points of the five views, taught it, discussed the different opinions about this in this way. Because of this, they developed into two different schools.  When we look at the real distinguishing, the different spiritual traditions, it taught us to speak about the five views. It does, says, that there are different factions developing of this. But it doesn’t say that it says, therefore, it doesn’t say that there are three factions.

So the Tibetan translation mentions three factions: the Nāga faction and the outline faction, and the learned factions.  But the Chinese sources talk about there being four factions of the Saṅgha. When they discussed the five points of Mahādeva, they had different opinions. Therefore, they divided into different schools. And when they divided into different schools, what happened is that there was a split into the two original schools.

The Chinese translation and the Tibetan tradition are not the same.  The Tibetan tradition says there were three factions, whereas the Chinese sources said there are four. Thus, there are some opinions about the difference in the translations. And I think I’ll speak about them in our next class.

9. The Original and Secondary Splits: the Northern Tradition

In any case, from the time that Buddhism taught by our teacher began, there was the time of early Buddhism, there was a time where there was a unified sangha. Later, that divided into two schools. We call this the original split into schools.  When the original split happened, there were the two schools, the Sthavira school and the Mahāsāṃghikas.

After these two schools had appeared, then gradually, within the next 100 to 200 years, even within these two major schools, they developed internally into many factions. So, in the end, there are actually a few dozen schools. So, the people talk about the secondary split into sub-schools. The original split was the split into the Sthavira school and Mahāsāṃghika. Then within themselves, they divided into many parts, these are called the split into sub-schools. In Tibetan, we talk about the split into the 18 schools. That is how the split into the 18 schools is primarily talking about the split into sub-schools.

Thus, from ancient times, there have been many documents from ancient times onwards about the split into the 18 schools and what their different philosophies are. Generally, we can say there are the documents from the northern tradition, and the documents from the southern tradition.

As I’ve spoken about before, I’m going to talk about the Northern tradition. Sometimes it includes both Chinese and the Tibetan Buddhism.  Sometimes within the northern tradition, we only speak about the Chinese tradition, and we don’t include the northern tradition.

If we have a broader version, then both the Tibetan and Chinese, are included in the northern tradition. If we take a more limited view, then the northern transmission only includes the Chinese tradition, but does not include the Tibetan.

So, sometimes we talk about three different transmissions, whether they are the southern, the northern, and the Tibetan transmissions. There are people who count it like that.

I think during this context, we could speak about the Tibetan tradition being included within the northern tradition. The only text we have to speak about is the Wheel Distinguishing the Different Schools by Vasumitra. So, here, we can consider that the Tibetan is included within the northern tradition. So,  I think there’s enough for today.

 

One thought on “The Origins and Development of Nikāya (Early Schools) Buddhism and the importance of lay followers and merchants in the early Buddhist “schools” tradition: 17th Gyalwang Karmapa, Mar-Ngog Summer Teachings (Day One)”

  1. wonder if any Buddhist saint refused patrons support & had other means? to avoid corruption, bias, elitism . if any saints attained full illumination & still do not need food, etc they have enlightened worlds . would like to mee those. should not sell mystic transmissions & deities. would need special patrons . i do not like patrons in some instances , makes it impossible to join . would like options. origins of secret mantra- also would like to know about rules safety for right sound speech, if saying mantras all the time for years -would need to check every few minutes that is correct sound otherwise would destroy yourself. who is in charge of that ?

Leave a Reply