Introduction and Summary
Recently, I visited Bhutan again for the third time this lifetime due to the publicly advertised events and visit of the 17th GyalwangKarmapa there. When it was announced over a month ago on social media (not the Karmapa Office official page) it was a major event for those of us who had waited many years to see him teach publicly in person again.
The last time I (and many others) had seen him “in the flesh” was in India in 2017. Although I had followed his movements, online teachings avidly, documenting and transcribing and expanding on them, as well as translating his Introductory research to new texts he had composed, I had wanted to meet him in person but had been unable to do so.
Even when I was in Bangkok several times, and last year bumped into the Karmapa’s sister and one of his monk attendants in a vegan restaurant there, even though I had requested it, they had not offered any assistance to help me meet him either. Strange considering how I had followed and produced so much work in connection with his teachings and activities over the past five years in particular. Yet movie actors and actresses, politicians, businessmen, sponsors had no issues getting such audiences. Samsaric worldliness or something more sinister?
This Bhutan visit brought moments of great bliss, beauty and blessing, alongside frustrating and disappointing experiences that left me asking difficult and unresolvable questions. My strongest connection and the reason I had come was always the 17th Karmapa. Receiving the Guru Padmasambhava empowerment from him in Thimphu on 6 November was one of the most precious experiences of the trip (which I will write about it more detail later). As were other sacred sites I had not visited before in Thimphu and Paro.
This account includes what I think of as the “official” narrative combined with my “on the ground” unsanitised narratives and experiences there. Alongside the photographs of religious leaders, VIP guests and public celebrations, there was everyday life in Thimphu. I saw a lot of cracked paving around Clock Tower Square and heard loud drinking and karaoke at night. I had read about concerns over drugs and alcohol among young people and about people leaving Bhutan to find work and other opportunities. Those wider issues deserve more research, but they formed part of the background to what I saw.
After the Guru Padmasambhava empowerment had finished, there was a distressing news report that a twelve-year-old girl had been sexually assaulted and killed in Thimphu and that four men had been arrested. It was reported that same day, 6 November. The thought of that child stayed with me alongside the celebrations.
Also, on the day of the 17th Karmapa’s arrival, news of a glacial lake outburst in northern Bhutan, near Punkaha, brought another reality into view. Global warming contributes to glacier loss, and the production and consumption of animal foods form part of the wider greenhouse-gas emissions driving climate change. These connections made me think about the consequences of everyday “eating animals” habits of consumption and the place of meat eating in a country that speaks so much about compassion, which I will also write more about.
Being a pilgrim “on the ground” with fellow ordinary devotees, I saw on social media and in person people sitting on bare ground earth in every photograph I encountered from Gelephu, while the VIP guests I later discovered had been staying at “ridicuilously expensive” 5 star hotels with advertised rates approaching £1,000 a night. There were plenty of other lovely resorts and hotels at a third of that price which would have been more than sufficient for the purposes. Particularly as many of the guests were monastics, who are supposed to be abandoning excess luxury and consumption. It reminded me a little when I was flown out for the VESAK day events in HCM city in Vietnam as an invited speaker. I was given a stunning room in a 5 star hotel, but it was around 150 GBP per night.
Although I’d planned to attend the Gelephu Mindfulness City events (1-4 November 2026) for the 108 stupas, I couldn’t find adequate transport to return from there in time for the main events in Thimphu. I also saw reports on social media from Bhutanese pilgrims struggling to get home, with too few taxis and high fares.
Against the luxury shown in the coverage of special guests, that lack of basic provision struck me deeply. The labels VIP and VVIP raised a related question. What do these distinctions mean at a Buddhist event, where practice, compassion and equanimity should guide how people are treated? Wouldn’t the labels, “invited guests, speakers or sponsors” have been more appropriate and respectful?
I return to that question later and in my reflections on other events and incidents. There was a public condemnation of the 108 Stupas as like an “IKEA pre-fabricated construction” by a Lhasa-based Tibetan female writer, Tsering Woeser, which seemed excessive but also clearly motivated by jealousy, and anti-Bhutan and anti-Karmapa sentiment, as demonstrated by her other posts, and as is often shown by those Tibetans aligned with Gelugpa “superiority” ideology.
In addition the lack of adequate public transport arrangements that would allow easy and affordable travel to and from Gelephu was disappointing considering the expense that had been thrown at the VVIP guests with private jets, gala dinners, helicopter rides and 5 star hotels. Surely some money could have been found to hire a fleet of semi-sleeper buses to go there and back every hour or so for the pilgrims, so that no one would be left without transport and stranded. They could have even charged a reasonable fee for the bus ticket.
At one of the publicly unnaounced visits (which I discovered only after seeing it on Facebook), I experienced being targeted as a woman alone, first by two policemand suddenly coming up on either side of me, leaving all the men I was standing next to, “unguarded”. At one point it made me wonder, am I being guarded from people attacking me, or vice versa! Then as soon as the Karmapa has passed me the police left me there, and when I again then tried to join the group of men next to me getting their blessings from Karmapa, another policeman suddenly appeared from nowehere blocking my access to a blessing while the men beside me were allowed. These experiences raised questions for me about the irrational fear of lone women, when the heavy male security presence left women feeling fearful, and was symbolic again of women’s treatment, material inequality and whose needs receive care, investment and attention. It also reminded me of the difficulties Sera Khandro experienced meeting her beloved guru.
In any case, this is the first instalment in a short series in which I describe preparing to go to Bhutan, arriving in Paro, practical difficulties and personal experiences and blessed meetings with the guru whom I had come specifically to see, 17th Gyalwang Karmapa.
Following instalments will consider:
—the Gelephu 108 Stupas and lack of adequate transport and facilities to attend.
—time visiting sacred places and uncovering previously unvisited stunning hidden heritage and historical “treasures” in Thimphu (3rd and 4th November 2026)
—attending two public events in the 17th Karmapa’s presence in Thimphu, at a Karma Kagyu monastery and then the grand empowerment in Thimphu (5th and 6th November 2026)
–visiting a sacred and ancient place in Paro, that revealed hidden wisdom and messages.
I will compile the accounts into an e-book with accompanying photos for free download, once completed.
Section 1: Preparing for Bhutan and arriving in Paro
The significance of the Karmapa’s return
When the 17th Karmapa’s visit to Bhutan was announced, it was a major event for those of us who had waited many years to see him teach publicly in person again. The last time I had seen him in person was in India in 2017.
Since then, there had been various challenges for the Karmapa, including legal proceedings in Canada involving allegations concerning a woman and a child, other sexual misconduct accusations, and the COVID pandemic.
Throughout those years, I continued to follow his online teachings, however, and produced many articles, transcripts and personal reflections on his teachings and circumstances and remained deeply devoted and dedicated to him.
That devotion did not mean that I had no questions, as others did too. I had written that a clear public statement about the Canadian legal proceedings would have been helpful. Clarity is important as a [art of wisdom in Buddhism, and honesty is fundamental to Buddhist vows. From what I had seen, there had not been a statement from the 17th Karmapa that clearly answered the questions troubling followers such as myself, and that had led so many into confusion and negative speech and gosisp [1].
Publicity and the absence of official schedules and tourist agency tours at a high price
The announcement of the 17th Karmapa’s visit to Bhutan came about a month before his visit, However, there was no official public schedule accompanying the announcement I saw. Unofficial schedules circulated on social media by travel agents, including one which said that he would arrive on the 29th and visit Paro Taktsang on the 30th. That was not how events unfolded though.
There may have been other people like myself who made their travel arrangements according to that unofficial schedule. When travelling a long distance and spending a considerable amount of money, even an indication of the dates can become the basis for booking flights and accommodation. Yet without an official programme, it was difficult to know which information could be relied upon.
The lack of an official public schedule was frustrating, although the unofficial schedules at least gave some indication of what might happen.
The 108 Stupas event in Gelephu Mindfulness City
The event involving the 108 stupas at Gelephu was clearly a monumental occasion, worthy of praise and admiration. Initially, the publicity placed particular emphasis on the Karmapa’s participation and his offering a stupa there for the event.
During the weeks leading up to it, however, I began seeing announcements featuring an increasing number of additional religious figures, including Sakya leaders and members of the Sakya family, other male Rinpoches, and even the elderly Ganden Tripa (head of the Gelugpa lineage)!
As more names and faces appeared, my feelings became more complicated. Many of these were male teachers I did not follow, and some were people towards whom I did not feel trust or devotion, and had seen their misconduct, dishonesty and malice directly, for reasons I have discussed elsewhere in my writing.
I was also struck by how overwhelmingly male the main guests were. Buddhism’s fourfold community comprises monks, nuns, lay women and lay men. Yet the promotional images I saw seemed to give very little comparable visibility to women. This raised familiar questions for me about who is presented as representing Buddhism and whose presence and contribution remain marginal.
The inclusion of the Ganden Tripa also gave me reservations because of my historical research and my views on Tibetan religious politics and history. For me, the event was beginning to look very different from the occasion I had initially hoped to attend.
That was my response to the publicity, rather than evidence that the organisers had deliberately changed the event’s purpose. Nevertheless, something I had first understood primarily as an opportunity to see the 17th Karmapa return to public teachings and events was increasingly being presented as a much broader gathering, with a variety of male teachers, some of whom I had no devotion or reverence for, with good reasons.
Why not a Karma Kagyu centre/monastery? Access for longstanding followers
Bhutan is expensive for foreign visitors. Flights are costly (500 USD for one way) and only two air, and the US$100 nightly Sustainable Development Fee is an additional expense before accommodation, food, guides and transport. These costs matter to followers who have maintained their connection for years but have limited financial means.
In my personal view, it would have been easier for many longstanding Karma Kagyu followers if an opportunity to receive teachings from the Karmapa in persona again had been organised at a Karma Kagyu centre or monastery, in a more accessible (affordable) country. For Karma Kagyu practitioners to gather around their lineage head, express their devotion and receive his teachings after such a long absence.
VIP or VVIP at Buddhist events and overwhelmingly male dominated with visible women related to biological inheritance and financial connections
For a genuine Buddhist practitioner, the focus is mainly on practice and benefiting others wherever they go, taking the path as the guru. For a worldly “Buddhist”, it can become about which VIP they met, their clothes and physical appearance, where they sat, whether they were invited to a VIP event, and how many photographs they could get with “celebrity Buddhists”.
I’ve never understood why the words VIP, “Very Important Person”, are used at Buddhist events. Then there is VVIP, “Very Very Important Person”, for those who seem to need that extra ego boost and sense of superiority. To me, Buddhism is about equality and equanimity. “Invited guests” or “sponsors” would be far more suitable terms, and less worldly and divisive.
Although I’d planned to attend the Gelephu Mindfulness City gathering for the 108 stupas, I couldn’t find a workable way to get there and return. I was a solo female foreign pilgrim, sponsored to make the journey, with ten years of work as a Dharma translator and practitioner connected to the Karma Kagyu and the Karmapa, as well as Buddhism more generally. I was travelling as a pilgrim, and I wasn’t on a VIP guest list.
It wasn’t just me. I saw reports on social media from Bhutanese pilgrims who were struggling to get to Gelephu and, particularly, to get home again. From those accounts, there weren’t enough taxis for the numbers needing them, and people were reporting high fares. I couldn’t find adequate public transport arrangements for the journey and return.
Meanwhile, the coverage seemed full of luxury for special guests. I thought of the private jets associated with this wider culture of religious events and hotel rooms advertised at rates approaching £1,000 a night. I didn’t know the actual costs or who had paid them. Even so, the contrast between the luxury on display and the difficulty of finding basic transport for pilgrims was striking. Why couldn’t there have been a fleet of tourist buses, with reclining seats for the long journey, taking pilgrims from Thimphu to Gelephu and back? People could have bought tickets at reasonable prices. I would gladly have paid for one. I wondered what such an arrangement would have cost compared with the expense of accommodating special guests in luxury.
The VIP and VVIP seating added to that sense of division. Looking at some of the social media coverage, I sometimes felt as though I were looking at a celebrity magazine or a Vogue fashion show. There was so much attention to wealth, designer clothes and physical appearance. Many of the women shown prominently alongside the monks and teachers were relatives, wives, wealthy supporters, or women whose appearance attracted attention. As I’ve said elsewhere, I have nothing against women enjoying beautiful clothes or looking attractive.
At a Buddhist event, one would hope the media emphasis would be on reducing attachment and excessive consumption, practising compassion and caring for others. The way the visit was presented sometimes seemed to encourage the very worldly ideals we’re supposed to be examining in ourselves. For pilgrims who couldn’t find a way home, I could understand how the contrast might cause frustration and annoyance.
I thought about the Buddha’s community and its ideal of looking beyond wealth, fame and family connections. To me, a person’s place in the Dharma should rest on their practice, realisations, qualities and vows. Those are the things I would want a Buddhist gathering to honour, not be some kind of “celebrity” event of social media selfies of monks meeting other monks, or the occasional woman who was there for biological, worldly or financial reasons. Even though most of the photos were of monks meeting other monks and endless white scarf offerings (what a waste of cloth!) as well as some very expensive looking gold Guru Padmasambhava statues handed out by the 17th Karmapa to the VIP visitors, it seemed very worldly, and I wondered how this was becoming the norm (or even acceptable) at Buddhist events.
What struck me most was which women were visible and who was almost invisible. I hardly saw any nuns. Where were the women being recognised in their own right for their practice, their scholarship, their translations or their knowledge of the Dharma? Buddha had twenty-three prominent female disciples he listed for such qualities. I kept coming back to that question. What did it say about whose contribution we valued when a woman’s family connections, physical appearance or social standing seemed to count for more than women who had spent years studying, practising without such connections or wealth? What message and role models were we giving women and girls?
Why Bhutan? Some observations about its spiritual, cultural and political importance to the Karmapas and Karma Kagyu and Tibetan exile politics
The significance of Bhutan as the setting for this visit is also notable. Bhutan has its own Buddhist institutions and religious history, distinct from the Tibetan exile Gelug-dominated establishment in India. Given my research into Tibetan Buddhist history (including Gelugpa takeovers of Tibet, Ladakh and attempted invasions of Bhutan)the setting carried political and symbolic significance.
Was it because Bhutan was able to offer circumstances and security in which the 17th Karmapa felt more able to appear publicly than returning to India? However, I did not know the reasons behind the decision and could not say that safety, religious politics or any particular institutional relationship had determined it. The 17th Karmapa himself spoke of the historical connection between the Karmapas and Bhutan during the Thimphu empowerment, which I will write more about later.
The Karmapa lineage has a strong prior c0onnection with Bhutan, as I have written about in relation to the 16th Karmapa (who was given a Bhutanese passport and a lot of land there too before he passed away). The 17th Karmapa spoke about this during the Three Roots Unified Thimphu empowerment on the 6th November, which I was fortunate to attend in person. In particular about the 10th Karmapa, Choying Dorje and his conneciton with the Bhutanese masters during the 17th Century.
The visit itself nevertheless prompted questions about the Karmapa’s independence, the representation of different lineages, and the relationship between religious authority and political influence. I will return to those questions when discussing the public ceremonies during the 108 Stupa event, including the seating arrangements and the visual and symbolic messages they conveyed.
At the end of the day, the Dalai Lama institution has long been backed by the U.S. government. I wonder whether there may have been an even higher political strategy at work, whether the U.S. government had an interest in maintaining the Dalai Lama’s political power and diminishing and demeaning the Karmapa. In my view, he would have been the ideal person to deal with the Chinese government. He speaks fluent Chinese, he came from Tibet, and he was recognised by the Chinese government there. So I feel this could potentially have been a political decision at a higher level too, one that may have affected relations between India and China [3].
In a way, the Bhutan visit was a sign of that for me. After nearly ten years, the place the Karmapa chose to make his first public appearance of this kind was Bhutan, the place where Zhabdrung Ngawang Namgyal came after fleeing Tibet. Bhutan itself faced several invasions by Mongolian forces with Gelugpa support. I see a strong historical and cultural reason why, to my knowledge, there are no Gelugpa monasteries in Bhutan to this day and the Dalai Lamas have never visited.
The Asian Visionary Summit and the Scholarship
Before I came to Bhutan (after booking a flight and paying for the daily fee for 9 days), I noticed that there was an Asian Visionary Summit also scheduled for 6 to 8 November. People like the actor Jet Li, and his daughter had been scheduled as guests. The lowest fee to attend was US$1,750 and the highest was US$10,000. That puts it out of reach for most people. I wondered how visionary a summit could be if who gets to attend depends on their ability to pay. To me, being a visionary is about one’s ideas and innovation, not on ability to pay.
They did have a scholarship, so I applied as the founder of the startup, Dakini Translations. I got a very enthusiastic email back almost immediately saying I’d got the scholarship. I still had to pay US$300, which is a large amount for most people, but they told me it would cover the Bhutan visa daily fee for all three days. I asked my kind sponsor if he would be willing to pay it, and he said yes.
It was quite difficult to wire the money to Bhutan though, so I emailed the organisers a couple of times while I was trying to find a way to do it, and there was no response. I thought that was strange because the email about the scholarship had come back almost immediately. As I was getting closer to coming to Thimphu, I decided I’d just send the money via Wise, which would take at least three working days to arrive.
When I told them I’d wired the money, I got an email back almost immediately, at around nine in the evening. They said they were sorry they hadn’t replied and had been very busy. They also said I could no longer attend at the scholarship rate. They’d decided I wasn’t eligible and would have to pay the full fee, but they didn’t explain why. I asked them why I was not eligible as I had founded it and it was about Dharma. They said I could go if I paid US$1,750 But I didn’t have that money, and I wasn’t willing to ask my sponsor to pay it. I think it’s a huge amount of money to attend a three-day conference. So I decided I would not go.
It’s hard to say why they suddenly changed their minds. I wondered whether someone might have spoken to them after hearing I’d been offered the scholarship, as part of the smear campaign I’ve been continually subjected to over the past five years. [1] . I did get the money back, but it left me feeling confused and again wondering if it was yet another example of clear “damage” caused by the smear campaign.
DAY ONE: ARRIVING IN PARO AND SEEING THE 17tH KARMAPA
Arriving in Paro on 29th October 2026
I arrived in Paro on the afternoon of the 29th October, with Druk Air, the day the Karmapa was also scheduled to arrive. It was very cloudy and, as we say in English, “chucking it down” with rain. There was hardly any visibility as we approached Paro Airport, which is known for its difficult landing between the mountains.
This was the first time I had flown into Paro in such cloudy weather and with so little visibility. On my previous visits, there had normally been blue skies and sunshine. As you come in, you fly between the mountains. On this occasion, I could see mountains on either side, sometimes peeking above the clouds, but very little else. It was a bit hair-raising, to say the least. With the heavy rain and what seemed to me such limited visibility, I wondered whether we would be able to land.
Yet the pilot brought us down very skilfully. I felt particularly appreciative of the skill involved in landing there in those conditions, as Paro is considered to be one of the most difficult landings on the planet, with only about fifty pilots trained to do it.
It is always beautiful to see Bhutan though, the mountains, rivers and unique architecture and old temple buildings. The people are on the whole, gentle, polite and welcoming.
A vegetarian welcome at Khamsum Inn
From the airport, I took a taxi to the hotel I had booked, Khamsum Inn. It was my first time staying there, and it was a vegetarian-only hotel. One of the very few, if only in Paro.
It was a really lovely place and the room was a good size for one person, with beautiful wooden panelling and a balcony overlooking the valley and surrounding mountains. It was not particularly expensive either—around US$25 per night. With the comfortable room, the views and the entirely vegetarian food, it was somewhere I would happily recommend to other vegetarian pilgrim travellers on a budget.
The only “challenge” was the weather. I had come from the heat and humidity of Bangkok, so the drop in temperature was noticeable. It was colder , and the rain was heavy and constant. It was a very different arrival in Paro from those I had experienced before.
I saw news on social media that a glacier had melted caused by the weather, and had flooded areas of Northern Bhutan, in and around Punakha.
The following day: news of the Karmapa’s arrival
At that point, I assumed that the Karmapa had already arrived, because that was what the unofficial schedule had stated. According to the same schedule, he would be visiting Paro Taktsang the following day. I had been considering going up to Taktsang again myself at the same time, and it would have been my third visit there.
However, looking at the weather and the continuing heavy rain, I felt that the proposed visit would surely have to be cancelled or delayed. I therefore stayed on in Paro the following day, having already booked my accommodation.
Without an official public schedule, it was uncertain about what was happening and when and whether the programme being circulated would take place.
An unexpected meeting on the road
On the 30th November in the late morning, I was sitting upstairs in a café in Paro, assuming that the Karmapa had arrived the previous day and was probably resting in his hotel, as no other events had been publicly announced. I was doing some writing on my laptop.
A Bhutanese woman came up and sat nearby. She was wearing a military-style jacket, and I thought she might be an official. When I asked, she told me she was a policewoman. There seemed to be preparations taking place on the main road below, so I asked whether they were waiting for someone. She said that a VIP was coming and I asked whether it was the Karmapa, she said yes.
I was surprised and explained that I thought Karmapa had already arrived, but she told me he was arriving at Paro Airport soon and they had delayed it. This was a day later than the unofficial schedule had indicated. It was still raining, although not as heavily as when I had arrived.
I thought that perhaps this would be a chance to greet him in person. Below the café, some local Bhutanese workers and guides from the shops were beginning to line the street despite the ongoing rain. As the time approached, I went downstairs to wait with them. The police had stopped the traffic, and I could see the cavalcade approaching. First came a police car, followed by the car carrying the Karmapa. As he passed, his window was open. He looked at me and gave me a huge grin.
I experienced that brief moment as a great blessing. It filled me with relief and happiness that I had finally been able to see him physically, even if only for a few seconds.
It reminded me of when I first met him almost twenty years ago at the monastery in Himachal Pradesh, India, where I had my first private audience with him, before later taking refuge vows with him in another private audience, alone.
I went back upstairs to the café feeling elated. I had also asked the policewoman where the Karmapa was going and what he would be doing but assumed he would go straight to his hotel. She mentioned something about Paro College, but did not explain what was happening there or whether members of the public could attend, and so I assumed it was a private event.
In hindsight, I wished I had paid more attention to that information and asked further questions. At the time, however, I decided to remain in the café. Sadly, the events with Gyalton Rinpoche and the false accusations in the Delhi court case, had made me hesitant to even try and get an audience at the hotel where he was staying. Yet other people did that without any hesitation (as I would have normally done).
Later, looking at social media, I saw videos of the Karmapa teaching in Paro College. I was disappointed personally to see it and could hardly believe that I had missed it while actually being there in the town. I also discovered that he had visited Kyichu Lhakhang (the oldest temple in Bhutan). One which I had visited before on my first trip to Bhutan. I later visited this temple again, and will write about that more later.
I had not seen any public announcement explaining these visits or how to attend. Even though I had told the policewoman that I had been following the Karmapa for almost twenty years, she had not mentioned these opportunities. Perhaps she did not know the details herself; I had no reason to assume that she was withholding information.
Nevertheless, the question remained: why had an official public schedule not been made available, even shortly before or after his arrival? People like myself travelled a long way and spent considerable money to be there. How were we supposed to know where to go, whether an event was public, or whether we could attend and receive those blessings?
Alongside the disappointment, I felt frustrated that information which could have made such a difference had been so difficult to find. As a lone, independent pilgrim, I had no organised group or guide passing on those details. But even those with guides said they had no idea what his schedule was or where he was staying.
I saw people waiting along the road when he arrived, but from where I stood I did not witness the scale of public greeting that I later understood some reports to describe. Other people may have seen a different part of the welcome. What I knew was that I had discovered his arrival almost by chance. I wondered how many other devotees had also missed opportunities because they could not find (or no-one told them) reliable information.
The Glaciers are melting: Heavy rain in Paro and Flooding in Punakha and eating animals
When the Karmapa arrived in Paro, it was raining heavily. It was cold and cloudy, and he was unable to go up to Paro Taktsang, as the unofficial schedule had suggested he would.
Around the same time, the news was reporting a glacial lake outburst in northern Bhutan. The flood swept downstream through Gasa and Punakha, and debris blocked the river where the Mo and Lungo meet, forming a new lake. It was striking to be following the news of the flood as the Karmapa arrived in Paro. In a small country with so many communities in narrow valleys, I kept thinking about how much damage a sudden flood could do. [1]
It reminded me of the devastating flood in 2025 near the Nepal–Tibet border, when a lake on a glacier in Tibet suddenly drained into the river below. I thought of the Kyirong route that, according to the life story I translated, Guru Padmasambhava took when he first entered Tibet at the invitation of the Tibetan king, to bring the Dharma and tame the unseen forces that were obstructing it. I’d spent so much time with that account that it was particularly sad to read about the destruction in the border area. [2]
Following the news from Punakha while I was in Paro also made me think about the natural environment and the choices we make every day. One question I had come to Bhutan to ask was how people here thought about eating meat in a Buddhist country. That was something I wanted to look at more closely during the trip.
A blessing in disguise
The teaching was subsequently made available on YouTube, and a transcript was later produced by the Kagyu Office. Ordinarily, transcribing or writing about such a teaching would have been something I might have done myself. This time, however, I felt deflated by the experience and wondered whether I had made a mistake by remaining in the café and should have followed the cars (as other devotees had done).
Then I remembered that brief meeting of minds, eyes and hearts as his car passed. I decided to hold on to that moment and consider whether there might also have been something positive in how the day had unfolded.
After the Delhi court case in my absence, the online smear campaign and false accusations, I also wondered whether being seen at the first day teaching or at Kyichu Lhakhang might have brought further difficulties for myself and the 17th Karmapa. I worried that people spreading false accusations about me could have used my presence there to cause trouble later in the trip.
Still, it helped me consider another possibility: sometimes, as we say in English, something disappointing can be a “blessing in disguise”. Perhaps missing those events had also spared me difficulties that I could not foresee. The disappointment remained, but so did the happiness of that brief encounter on the road.
After Paro, I continued to Thimphu to visit its sacred places, including the great Memorial Stupa and Buddha Dordenma. With the plan that I would travel to Gelephu Mindfulness City for the major empowerment happening there advertised on the 4th November. That plan and journey did not go as expected/planned though, which may have been a protective and positive thing in hindsight.
Instead the initial “losses” turned into a revelatory visit to two “hidden treasures” in Bhutan, which had more beauty, power and profound meaning than I could ever have envisaged or imagined. More on that in the following chapters….
Endnotes
I believed that many devoted followers would have been willing to listen to an honest explanation, whether that involved acknowledging a mistake, denying an allegation, or explaining which aspects of what was being reported were accurate and which were not. Without that clarity, uncertainty remained, creating space for gossip, speculation and people speaking on his behalf without necessarily knowing the full facts.
As an advocate for women and survivors, I maintained that we should not simply assume that the women making allegations were lying. Equally, allegations should not automatically be treated as established facts. I wanted to hear his account, while recognising that any response would also need to be considered alongside the evidence.
My own experience made these questions particularly significant to me. I had faced what I regard as a severe online smear campaign, which intensified from 2024 onwards and included a website containing accusations I have publicly disputed as false. I felt I had little choice but to respond publicly. That experience reinforced my sense of how damaging uncertainty and unchallenged accusations can become.
ENDNOTES
[1] I can give other examples of funding and support being withdrawn specifically citing my being a survivor of lama misconduct. I can also give examples of people who were very enthusiastic about my work, and offered support and published articles and interviews with me, and then suddenly stopped communicating without any explanation. There are situations I can document where I lost funding and was told so directly, or where I was unable to attend an empowerment and was given a clear statement about it in an email. It’s harder to know what’s happened in these more subtle situations, where I lose a chance to connect with people who might be able to help or fund my work.
For me, that’s one of the most sinister aspects of it all. There’s the reputational, emotional and spiritual damage, and there’s also the financial damage. I’ve often had very little funding and very little money in my bank account. As a lone mother, that’s been very difficult at times. I’ve lost opportunities for funding and opportunities to meet people, connect with projects and find people who might be able to sponsor my work.
[3]By constantly maintaining the Dalai Lama as the superior and sole leader of Tibet, as the head in exile, I feel that someone like the Karmapa, who could have provided some movement and whom both the Chinese and Indian governments recognised, was effectively blocked. In my view, the Gelugpas continually sought to maintain their power and superiority, a claim to power that came from the seventeenth century and was based on violence. I think India and China could have had much closer, more harmonious and amicable relations, and I wonder whether people in the Indian government are now starting to understand the kind of obstacle this may have created.
I think people are slowly starting to question this approach and the narrative that’s been maintained. I see the attacks on women like myself as part of that too. To me, it’s part and parcel of male patriarchal monasticism, and I wonder whether it’s also part of a general political strategy to maintain Gelugpa power, so that the U.S. can maintain its power in the region. It could be operating at that level of government. I think this needs to be looked at more and considered more closely.